Connect With Us

FacebookTwitterRSSYoutube

Media Coverage Of Malawi Convictions Erases Chimbalanga’s Identity As A Woman

05/21/10-by Bridgette P. LaVictoire
At what point is a gay man not a gay man? When she is a woman. The case in Malawi has shown something rather horrific about the media and about even the LGBT media. The couple who were sentenced to fourteen years in prison for “unnatural acts” is not a gay couple. They are a straight couple. Tiwonge Chimbalanga does not identify as a man; instead, she identifies as a woman. This creates something of an inconvenient narrative for many media outlets. This information is coming to light only just now. Several quotes from Ms Chimbalanga have been altered or ignored by many media outlets in order to make this about a gay couple instead of a straight couple involving a man and a transwoman.

One statement by Ms Chimbalanga goes “I am just a woman who loves my man. I’d rather remain in prison than to be released into a world where I am kept away from Steven.” However, the way this was printed was “I’d rather remain in prison than to be released into a world where I am kept away from Steven.”

The New York Times noted this stating:

Tiwonge Chimbalanga looked like a man but said he was a woman. He helped with the cooking and dressed in feminine wraparound skirts. Steven Monjeza was a quiet, sullen man often intoxicated on sorghum beer. He said he had never been happy until he finally met the right companion.

In a world without sex change operations and hormone replacement therapy, many transgender individuals often simply dress and act in a manner that identifies them with the proper gender. Many transgender individuals in years and centuries past simply dressed as women or men instead of undergoing surgeries which changed their bodies. For some female-identified-men (that is a female gender in a male/man’s body), castration was an option to allow a woman to feel more at home with her own body.

Classifying Ms Chimbalanga as a gay man erases her identity. Audacia Ray at Akimbo states the rest more clearly than I can:

This is a multilayered issue: clearly, trans and gay rights activists within Africa are identifying Tiwonge as a trans woman and see her conviction as transphobic state violence and injustice. However, mainstream international press and gay rights groups are coopting the story to fit into their concept of the fight for marriage equality. The resulting coverage both silences trans women and ignores the voices and identities of Africans.

Ironically, one of the few sources outside of Africa to make mention of this being an issue of gender identity is the statement from the White House condemning the convictions:

The United States strongly condemns the conviction and harsh sentencing of Steven Monjeza and Tiwonge Chimbalanga in Malawi. The criminalization of sexual orientation and gender identity is unconscionable, and this case mars the human rights record of Malawi. We urge Malawi and all countries to stop using sexual orientation or gender identity as the basis for arrest, detention, or execution.

The media tends to erase gender identity as a whole. While some are very blatant about their disdain and hatred for transpeople, others may be supportive but often slip in their terminology or their statements regarding a person’s real gender.

Unfortunately, this erasure of transgender identity and the tendency to equate transpeople as being “men in dresses” (let us ignore the fact that there are transmen as well), tends to do as much as possible to dismember the identity of transpeople and make it harder for them to live. The media needs to do more to counter act this problem moving forward.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Comments

comments

Share This Post

11 Responses to Media Coverage Of Malawi Convictions Erases Chimbalanga’s Identity As A Woman

  1. Pingback: Catherine Winters

  2. Pingback: Eduarda Santos

  3. Pingback: Laura Miller

  4. Pingback: Laura Miller

  5. Pingback: Aimee Menard

  6. Angela Erde

    May 23, 2010 at 2:32 am

    “Yet Chimbalanga told the New York Times in February: “I have male genitals, but inside I am a complete woman. Maybe I cannot give birth to a child, but I menstruate every month – or most months – and I can do any household chores a woman can do.” … ”

    On the evidence of that statement, Chimbalanga is intersex.

    • Bridgette P. LaVictoire

      May 23, 2010 at 8:13 am

      Angela,

      Until medical tests can be conducted, I have to, unfortunately, go with what can be verified. I actually understand where Ms Chimbalanga is coming from since I have had a menstrual cycle (sans menses) since I was 14. I have all the other physical symptoms including those not usually found in the medical journals. Unfortunately, getting doctors to listen and test is impossible.

    • Angela Erde

      May 23, 2010 at 11:15 pm

      Bridgette, why be beholden to doctors at all?

      Look at what they have done to intersex with their (or rather, Alice Dreger’s and ISNA’s) invention of DSD – Disorders of Sex Development. Doctors’ pathologization of intersex via DSD, their exclusion of many intersex via the invention of DSD, their surgical experimentation on the bodies of intersex newborns, their refusal to follow up on the result of what they do to intersex lives, their century-plus of quilting, shaming and silencing intersex people, their approach to intersex that is anything but humane or scientific, hardly qualifies them as any sort of experts or humanitarians.

      It is up to us to declare our intersex, not them.

      http://oiiaustralia.com/about/intersex/
      http://oiiaustralia.com/about/genital-cutting/

    • Bridgette P. LaVictoire

      May 23, 2010 at 11:27 pm

      Angela,

      Because, as a reporter and editor of this site, I have to have standards. That means that, without confirmation, I have to go with the evidence.

      On a personal level, I have to start with the fact that i know a lot more than i usually write about here regarding intersexed conditions, and the treatment of intersexed individuals by the doctors. Western medicine is not a very conducive to health, to be honest. At least not the bulk of it.

      I am in the process of transitioning from being physically male to being physically female. i am concerned about what a diagnosis of intersexuality will mean for me since there are health complications that might be there if I do not know, but therre is also the prejudices associated with it in the medical community. Trust me, starting at 14 (menarche), i had nightmares of doctors operating on me and taking away what made me female. I’ve been aware of this for a very long time. Twenty-one years now.

  7. Pingback: skirts women

  8. Pingback: Shenex Prom Dress